Weapons

Weapons

How to Really Fish weapons tier guide: which weapons handle dangerous fish, which ones you need before the Giant Crab, and the best buy order.

S-C
Tier System
Boss Grade First
Key Point

Introduction

Weapons exist in How to Really Fish for one blunt reason: the fish bite back. Wild catches can damage and kill you, and the Giant Crab is nearly impossible without proper weaponry. The weapon system is ranked in tiers that mirror your progression: you start with free gear that barely holds off commons, graduate to melee starters for early survival, then ranged weapons that let you fight dangerous fish from a safe distance, and finally heavy weapons built for boss fights. The community's buy order is clear — upgrade your starting gear quickly, get a ranged option before you venture into rare-water territory, and save cash for a heavy weapon before you tackle the Giant Crab. Because survival is woven into fishing, learning which weapon you need for each situation keeps you alive and keeps your cash from bleeding into repeat deaths.

Weapon Tier Quick Reference

TierWeapon TypeBest AgainstBuy When
SHeavy WeaponsBoss fights (Giant Crab)Before first boss raid
ARanged WeaponsDangerous fish from afarEntering rare water
BMelee StarterEarly survival vs commonsFirst upgrade
CFree Starting GearNothing seriousReplace quickly

Weapon Tier Breakdown

S

Heavy Weapons

legendary

The boss-grade arsenal that wins the Giant Crab fight

EffectHeavy weapons deal the serious damage bosses need. They are the community's requirement before attempting the Giant Crab, and they carry you through the hardest water.
WhenSave cash and buy before your first boss raid. Going into the Giant Crab with starter gear is the fastest way to lose supplies and confidence.
AdviceTreat heavy weapons as a progression gate: you are not prepared for endgame water until you own one and know how to use it.
A

Ranged Weapons

epic

The safe-distance option for dangerous fish

EffectRanged weapons let you damage dangerous fish and bosses without standing in their attack range, trading some punch for much safer positioning.
WhenGrab one before you start fishing rare water where fish attack — they keep you alive long enough to learn each encounter's telegraph.
StrategyA reliable ranged option makes co-op easier too: you can contribute damage from safe positions while the tank holds aggro.
B

Melee Starter Weapons

rare

The first real weapon for early survival

EffectMelee starter weapons give you a fighting chance against common attackers during the first hours. They are cheap, easy to use, and teach basic combat timing.
WhenBuy one as your first weapon upgrade once you have some cash, before venturing beyond the safest shore spots.
AdviceDo not over-invest in melee weapons — step up to ranged as soon as rare water appears on your fishing route.
C

Free Starting Gear

common

The default loadout you must replace quickly

EffectYour starting gear is enough to survive a few shallow-water commons but crumples against anything serious. It exists so you can learn combat before spending cash.
WhenUse it for your first session and replace it with a melee starter as soon as you have a few hundred cash.
RuleNever enter boss water with starting gear — the Giant Crab will remove you from the island faster than any fishing lesson.

Core Mechanics

Weapons in How to Really Fish are the survival layer of a game that is nominally about fishing. When you catch a dangerous fish or challenge a boss, the encounter switches from reeling to combat: you deal damage with your equipped weapon, avoid the creature's attacks, and try to outlast it with healing food. The tiers reflect range and power. Free starting gear barely handles commons, melee starters teach you timing, ranged weapons trade power for safe distance, and heavy weapons deliver the damage bosses require. Because every catch is a potential fight, weapon choice should match your fishing plan: stay light for safe shore grinding, switch to ranged when you enter rare-water zones, and bring heavy weapons on any boss raid. Combat and fishing share the same survivability budget — the food you use to heal during a fight is food you did not sell, so better weapons indirectly protect your income.

Advantages

Owning the right weapon keeps you alive, and staying alive protects your money. Deaths waste food, time, and sometimes your best catches, so a good weapon is an investment that pays back every session. Ranged weapons add a huge safety margin: you can farm rare water and contribute to boss fights without standing in the danger zone. Heavy weapons are the key that unlocks boss content, turning the Giant Crab from a wall into a farmable target for loot. The tier buy order also gives clear cash priorities, so you never dump money into a weapon you will replace in an hour. And because combat and fishing share resources, learning weapons early makes your whole money loop safer and faster.

Challenges

Weapon specifics are the least documented area of the game because the developers have not published a full weapon catalog, so tier descriptions are community-reported rather than official. Damage values and prices can change with beta balance patches, meaning a weapon that felt strong last week may feel weaker after an update. Heavy weapons are expensive, and buying one too early can starve your money loop just like buying a boss lure too early. Solo players also depend heavily on their weapon because they cannot rely on a tank to hold aggro, which makes weapon mistakes more punishing in solo boss attempts.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I really need weapons to play?+
Yes — How to Really Fish's signature twist is that fish fight back. Wild catches can damage and even kill you, and the Giant Crab is nearly impossible without proper weaponry. Even casual players should keep at least a melee starter for early survival and upgrade to ranged before exploring rare-water zones. Skipping weapons entirely guarantees painful deaths once the game stops being a pure fishing trip.
What weapon should I buy before the Giant Crab?+
Buy a heavy weapon before your first Giant Crab attempt. Heavy weapons deal the serious damage the boss fight demands, and going in with starter gear is the fastest way to burn through your healing food and supplies. If you are short on cash, a ranged weapon is a partial stopgap, but plan the heavy weapon as your real gate into boss content.
Are ranged weapons better than melee?+
Ranged weapons are safer but lighter: they let you damage dangerous fish from a distance, which is ideal for rare-water grinding and co-op boss fights from safe positions. Melee weapons can feel stronger point-blank but force you into the danger zone. For most players, a ranged option is the better general-purpose pick once you leave shallow water.
When should I upgrade my weapon?+
Upgrade as soon as the next tier enables your plan: a melee starter right after your first earnings, a ranged weapon before you enter rare-water zones, and a heavy weapon before any boss raid. The tier buy order protects your cash because each weapon earns back its cost through safer, faster farming.

Quick Tips

💡

Upgrade in this order — melee starter for early survival, ranged for rare water, heavy before any boss raid — and never skip straight to heavy while you are still learning. Graduating through the tiers in order teaches you the timing each weapon needs, so you are never stuck learning a boss tool for the first time mid-fight.

💡

Use a ranged weapon when farming rare water solo: the safe distance keeps you alive long enough to learn each dangerous fish's attack pattern. Staying at range against rare water attackers lets you learn each pattern without feeding the encounter your healing food. The difference between a casual session and a serious grind is exactly this kind of deliberate, repeatable routine.

💡

Never enter boss water with starting gear — a quick weapons purchase before the Giant Crab saves more supplies than the weapon itself costs. A quick purchase before the boss saves you from replacing lost gear and supplies later, so the weapon more than pays for itself. Make it part of your standard loop and the benefit shows up in every single catch you take.

💡

Treat weapon upgrades as income protection: fewer deaths means fewer wasted catches and less money spent on repeated healing food. Better weapons mean fewer deaths, which protects both your storage and your morale; every run you finish is progress you keep. Top players treat these rules as automatic; the sooner you internalize them, the smoother your whole progression feels.

Explore More